Is the "redirect=ok" query string necessary? – UserPro Forums https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/feed/ Sat, 18 May 2024 09:03:33 +0000 https://bbpress.org/?v=2.6.2 en-US https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-18978 <![CDATA[Is the "redirect=ok" query string necessary?]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-18978 Sun, 26 Jan 2014 17:12:28 +0000 Jer1479 Is the “redirect=ok” query string that shows up after a redirect serving any functional purpose that would break if it wasn’t there? I really would prefer not to have it making my urls more verbose if it’s not absolutely necessary. It also makes the page show up in a lot of analytics services as a unique page. For example, “site.com/some-page” and “site.com/some-page?redirect=ok” show up as two different pages in Google Analytics even though they’re identical. I realize that selectively ignoring specific query strings can be fixed on the GA end, but that’s not the point. I use several analytics services across several sites, so it would be great if the query string could be omitted if it isn’t doing anything other than notifying about a successful redirect. (the fact that a redirect happened is enough to show a successful redirect, right?)

I found and removed the string from the plugin code and used the plugin for several days with no issue, but with all the updates I obviously keep overwriting my fix.

If it’s doing something useful, great. Would love to know what that is. But if it’s purely informational, can it be officially removed or shut off with an option?

Keep up the great work! Thanks!

Jeremy

]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-18979 <![CDATA[Reply To: Is the "redirect=ok" query string necessary?]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-18979 Sun, 26 Jan 2014 17:17:13 +0000 I personally believe that is a good idea. However, I’m not the one who knows what is being done or how it is being done, so I can’t speak any further than it seeming like a good idea. 🙂

]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-19032 <![CDATA[Reply To: Is the "redirect=ok" query string necessary?]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-19032 Sun, 26 Jan 2014 23:15:25 +0000 admin Hi Jeremy,

I’ve fount that without this parameter, the URL is not notified about a change (Sometimes) so even when you login, you can appear as non-logged in until you refresh the page! That’s why I added this query string to enforce hard refresh.

I am open to ideas, I am afraid that If I remove it, the same problem will start to occur again. especially on cached websites and pages.

]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-19035 <![CDATA[Reply To: Is the "redirect=ok" query string necessary?]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-19035 Mon, 27 Jan 2014 01:34:58 +0000 Jer1479 Hey Ahmed,

Since it’s not a big deal and I’m probably one of the only people that actually cares about this, I’d be happy to try to work on a solution and contribute back to the plugin if I sort it out. Have you been able to reliably reproduce the issue? If so, when does it happen? I’ve tried every platform and browser I can get my hands on and have not been able to produce that problem.

]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-19036 <![CDATA[Reply To: Is the "redirect=ok" query string necessary?]]> https://forum.userproplugin.com/forums/topic/is-the-redirectok-query-string-necessary/#post-19036 Mon, 27 Jan 2014 01:41:46 +0000 admin I’ve removed it from the live demo, and will monitor it for sometime. Please let me know if you noticed any glitch

]]>